Why even have a press if…

“If you’re just going to repeat press releases, why have the press?” – Dan Lyons.

That’s fantastic insight from Lyons in these times of churnalism. Lyons was supposedly banned from CNBC for telling one of its reporters to apologize to viewers for being serially wrong about Steve Jobs’ health.

Instead of Lyons being banned from the network for calling out a reporter who refused to admit he was responsible for regurgitating spin, CNBC should look into doing some real journalism and tightening its editorial standards. Plenty of journalists do real journalism and know how to separate spin from fact. You can’t be a good journalist if you believe whatever people tell you.

In fact, the best advice I can ever give a young journalist is to not believe anything anyone tells you without corroborating evidence. People are always trying to use journalists. Watch this clip and see how several CNBC reporters/anchors/non-journalists defend their inability to act as a filter.

This entry was posted in State of journalism and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://editor.blogspot.com Howard Weaver

    This qualifies as “fantastic insight”? Come on, Patrick.

    “If your mother says she loves you, check it out” has been standard advice to reporters at least since I started 40 years ago. Insight??

    Oh, I don’t know exactly who you’re accusing of being “serially wrong” about Jobs health, but it does turn out that the folks who thought Apple wasn’t being candid look a little smarter today.

  • http://www.patthorntonfiles.com pat

    @Howard,

    It’s not great insight, but it’s amazing to me how powerful, connected, well-paid MSM outlets can mail it in. Look at how CNBC defends their poor coverage of this story.

    One of the CNBC hosts even said something along the lines of: “that’s the dirty little secret of journalism…we have to depend on our sources to tell us the truth.”

    Ummm… What? Are job is not to report everything people tell us. That’s called being used.

    The only person I’m accusing of being serially wrong is Jim Goldman. He has botched this story. He is the person that Dan Lyons is taking to task in this clip.

    Goldman told viewers not to long ago to avoid blogs because they reported in accurate information and rumors. Well, it turns out that Goldman and CNBC were the ones reporting inaccurate information.

  • http://sellingprint.blogspot.com Michael Josefowicz

    Just another example of the 85% rule.

    85% of the world do their jobs badly. Of the 15% who do their jobs well, 85% of those act like assholes. That leaves 2.25% that you want to talk to.”

    The good news is that it usually only takes 2.25% to change the world. The other 85% will come along for the ride.

blog comments powered by Disqus