Newspapers should get smaller to get better
Thursday, March 6th, 2008Newspaper staffs are shrinking and niche Web sites are popping up all over the place.
Newspapers and staffs should get physically smaller and only cover what is in their niches. Some papers have technology sections, movie review sections, health sections, etc. Those are all non-local niches.
A newspaper will get killed trying to compete in that space. Why would I want want to read tech news in a newspaper when I can get better and more current news from sources like Engadget and CNET? I knew about Apple’s iPhone SDK announcement while it was happening. Why would I want to read about it the next day? (Hint: I don’t.)
Why should I care what a local movie reviewer has to say when there are niche sites like Movies.com that provide much more in depth coverage and useful features like movie times and upcoming release dates?
Mens Health/Womens Health are both way better than any health and fitness section I have ever seen in a newspaper. If you’re not ESPN or Sports Illustrated, you should probably not be covering national sports. I know I’m not reading it.
But there are things that Mens Health, ESPN, Movies.com, etc can’t do that a local newspaper can do: namely cover a local community. Many people call it hyper local, but I think hyper local is where our focus should have been all along. Local is why people buy the local paper.
I know of a sports editor for a weekly newspaper that uses his sports column to write about national sports issues. There are countless columnists and talking heads who do a much better job. People aren’t reading the local people to read his thoughts on national sports, especially since he doesn’t even cover or travel to national sporting events.
I know of a small daily newspaper that asked a copy editor to review cell phones for a one-time feature. Not only is she not a technology writer, but she is also not a writer in general. If someone wants to know about cell phones they’ll go to one of the many strong technology Web sites and blogs (by people who cover technology for a living).
This is why newspapers should get smaller. Getting smaller will make them more focused. I don’t just mean cutting a few pages here or there or trimming the width of the paper. I mean cutting out whole sections and positions that make no sense for a local publication.
The Web is the home of the niche audience. The only niche that a newspaper has is its local market. Stick to it.
Many newspapers have been shrinking in recent years, yet they are still trying to cover as many beats and put out similar levels of copy. Does anyone honestly believe that writers and copy editors will magically be able to turn out the same quality of work while doing much more of it each day? No one with a brain does, and this is why newspapers are constantly printing mistakes and running embarrassing corrections.
Quality will trump quantity any day of the week. And maybe what we know as a local newspaper will have to change drastically. Maybe we’ll need to completely blow up how we cover news in order to cover it better.
I’m fine with that because what newspapers have been doing hasn’t been working.
